Search Commerce News

Monday, September 8, 2008

Treaty issues at grassroots of Gitxsan society

Speakers gather around the treaty issue in Gitanmaax Hall Sep 4 08, Old Town Hazelton, B.C

PHOTO CREDIT  Mack McColl  : .

Delgamuukw (Earl Muldoe) is from Gitxsan territory where the town of Hazelton, B.C. lays a'centre. Those people of Gitxsan heredity are examining treaty options as autumn 2008 ensues.

The Gitxsan Treaty Society (GTS) released a document, Alternative Governance Model, earlier this year, which has caused debate to ensue at Gitxsan meetings at Gitanmaax Hall and in the communities. (Realize how important treaty issues are to the thousands of Gitxsan.)

Gitxsan hereditary governance systems (and oral traditions) are the legal core that re-established Aboriginal Rights and Title in Supreme Court of Canada in 1997. The Ayookw (Indian Law) was revived.

"Delgamuukw, also known as Earl Muldoe, suing on his own behalf and on behalf of all the members of the Houses of Delgamuukw and Haaxw (and others suing on their own behalf and on behalf of thirty-eight Gitksan Houses and twelve Wet'suwet'en Houses." (Source: Judgements of the Supreme Court of Canada)

Delgamuukw won, and the judgement called for 'accommodation' of Aboriginal Rights and Title. This recognition of hereditary and other clan rights changes the political interest of the 33,000 sq. km. of Gitxsan. (Interpretations put the area as large as 57,000 sq. km.)

The GTS said, "The Gitxsan wish to step back from what has gone before, setting aside for the moment and opening a new and more productive initiative," in their Alternative Governance Model document.

"Governments have long said that settlements must respect local conditions and traditions. We agree, and in that spirit propose a specific Gitxsan approach to our future relationship with the governments of Canada and B.C..

"Our discussions so far have been based on the standard B.C. Treaty model which involves treaty settlement land and a new form of Indian government which would replace Indian Act Bands and Councils. . . ."

The society said, "We understand a government preference for a model . . . into which you have invested a great deal of legal effort and political capital. We do not criticize this. We say only that for us, there is a better way, and we ask you to join with us in exploring that road."

The society clarified, "We have no wish to receive any coercive power over our members, or to engage in any separate level of taxation." They claim, "only the right of all Canadians to benefit from the services paid for by taxes paid by us and others."

In fact, "The sole purpose of Gitxsan governance is internal for the management of collective Gitxsan assets and the preservation of traditions," and, "the current governance system (Ayookw) demonstrably does this adequately now, and has since time immemorial."

And added this resonant statement: "Any agreement must of course end the application of the Indian Act, including the Band governance structure imposed under the law. The Gitxsan are yet to accept Band councils and reserves."

Continuing, "The laws and services currently applied by the Indian Act councils can be better and more efficiently provided by federal and provincial entities as for all other British Columbians. We will naturally expect a voice in the mode of delivery to the Gitxsan, but we accept the management and infrastructure in place."

From the society's point of view, "The Gitxsan are not interested in the concept of 'treaty settlement lands.' Rather we wish to remain in a relationship with the entire 33,000 sq. km. of traditional territory.
"The economic value of our collective interest (which is neither fee simple nor sovereign but is certainly real, court ordered, and subject to definition) is to be realized by the process of 'accommodation' as articulated by the Supreme Court of Canada."

While the GTS looks forward to discussing "details of accommodation," the society's current process contains an optimistic tone, "We take encouragement from the fact that we have working models in place known to all parties at the table, which are the result of just such accommodation."

Gitxsan have taken jurisdictional over forests, the Carbon Credits Plan (biomass), and watersheds, "which encompass the whole of our traditional territory. . ."

Ratification of agreements, "may impose some complexities," including differences held by eight local Bands, including non-Gitxsan members of some of the Bands, and some reserve residents being non Indian.

"Since ratification of a settlement should be done by Gitxsan alone. . .some provision will be required for the non-Gitxsan . . ."
The society said, "We suggest that this is appropriate responsibility for Canada as the architect of the current Band structure.

"We came to the table as committed Canadians, paying our taxes and contributing to the country. We seek no special status nor any parallel society. We wish to live as ordinary Canadians in our way in a multicultural society. Further, we wish to pay our own way."

The GTS stated, "Our claim, and our only distinct claim, is to the inherited collective rights of our ancestors including those confirmed by the Supreme Court of Canada in Delgamuukw."

The society observed, "All Canadians have the right to inherit property. So do we. Our inheritance is an interest in the lands making up our traditional territory."

It is those 'interest' accommodations the GTS wishes to negotiate. "The Gitxsan governance system has evolved over many centuries. Our civilized approach to taking care of our community has not simply come out of a piece of legislation."

The Ayookw, "that guide(s) the Gitxsan people (has) a solid foundation of fairness, honour, respect, truth, openness, inclusiveness, accountability, and responsibility.

"The underlying principle of democracy as espoused by JS Mill, Aristotle, Plato, Machieavelli, and others from across the pond, is the same as what Delgamuukw, Guxsan, Sakumhiigookw, Dinimget, Gitludaalth, and many other Gitxsan thinkers defend."

Meetings in Gitxsan will continue through the fall and winter.

Wildwood Resources Ltd. Fire Fighting S100A Refresher Course

This Course Creates Wildfire Fighting  Safety Preparedness

Business Commentary

Jobs

Housing

Silviculture

Forestry

Salmon

Salmon Growers Unified on the West Coast

Environmental Readiness

Carpenter skills, among other elite skills

Popular Reading in 2026

Fly on the Wall Commentaries (Public Safety)

VISIT MCCOLL MAGAZINE PUBLIC SAFETY

Search Topics on Commerce News Label

2008 Aboriginal Abstraction activism AFN Agriculture AI Alberta Alberta forestry Alberta industry alcohol policy Alert Bay aluminum market America2Nite Angeliques Native Arts Anne McLellan Apprentice April Aquaculture archeology art Artificial Intelligence Atlantic cod Atlantic salmon automation Award B.C. B.C. Hydro Barkley Sound BC BC Aboriginal Woman of Distinction Award BC aquaculture BC coast BC energy BC forestry BC forestry crisis BC Hydro BC Salmon Farmers BC salmon industry Beau Dick BeauDickDavidGarrick beef prices biofuel biotechnology birch bark biting Blowback Dispatch blue commerce brain drain brands BRAZIL Brian Jean British Columbia Brookfield HQ Broughton Archipelago Building trades bureaucracy Burns Lake First Nation business Business Industry Business Profiles Business‑to‑Business Relations Bute Inlet Bute Inlet Power Project Calgary convention Camp Canada Canada Day Canada LNG Canada politics Canada trade Canadian economy Canadian energy Canadian exports Canadian federalism Canadian GDP Canadian households Canadian industry Canadian nation building Canadian politics Canadian workers Canfor Northwood Cannabis Economy capital flight 2025 capital investment Cardium Career Retrospective careers Carpenter Carpenters carving Cedar certification Chinook Christian worship Church Street cigar retail cigars civilization Civilizational Analysis clean energy politics climate impacts coal coastal economy cod cognitive economy Comedy Industry Commentary Commerce News Commercial fishery Commission of Government companies compensate Conservative Party construction construction economics Continental Politics convention Cooperative Decision Management copper corruption cost of living crisis cost-efficient energy Crafts CRCBC Criminal Justice Shift culinary history Cult TV Culture customs Daily Special Danielle Smith dark humor December 9 deeds over words democracy demographic Devonian DFO Domtar Crofton dystopia east coast economic analysis Economic Development economic policy economic strain Economics editorial justice Education elite emigration Canada energy energy corridor Energy History energy policy enrolment environmental policy equity ownership ethics Eulachon farmed fish federal politics fee simple grants Fernwood2Nite fibre supply Finance First Nation First Nations First Nations Emergency Services Society (FNESS) First Nations Forestry First Nations jurisdiction First Nations stewardship fiscal history fish farm fisheries FNNBOA FNNBOA Housing 3DRBI food culture food inflation food security food wild salmon Forest Products Industry forest restoration Forestry Forestry Business Forestry Contractors Forestry Industry forestry policy Forestry Technology Forestry Tradeshow Forestry Work foster care Fraser River Fraser Valley Fred Willard Friendship Centre generics Geology GIS global markets Globalization Governance graduates Harbour City Heritage Fund history Homalco Nation homes hostels Housing Housing Inspections housing standards human labor Human Systems HumanAI humidor humour Hydro hydro development hypocrisy Indian Reservation Indigenous Indigenous Canada Indigenous economic development Indigenous Education Indigenous Land Rights Indigenous leadership Indigenous Partnerships Indigenous Reconciliation Indigenous Rights and Title IndigenousSalmonFarms Industrial Agriculture industrial strategy Industry inland Innergex institutional distrust intergovernmental relations investment investment outflow Japan job losses Canada Jobs joint ventures Kiewet King Salmon Kitasoo Seafoods Klahoose Klemtu Labrador history land and resources land based Land Management leadership review leasehold legality Les Neasloss Liberal Government life sciences loghome Mack McColl Management manifesto companion Manitoba Mark Carney Martin Mull materials pricing McColl Magazine McColl Magazine Commerce mental health mentors Mesopotamia mill closures minerals mining mocassins modern cuisine Moderna Laval Monetary Theory Monika Murray Mortgage Namgis Nanaimo national competitiveness National Construction Council National Markets national productivity national stability Native Article 1 Native Article 2 Native Articles Native Arts natural gas natural resources NCFNG netpen Newfoundland Newfoundland Confederation Newfoundland debt crisis news report Nicol Street Hostel no veto Norman Lear North North America Northern B.C. NorthWestPacific ocean oil and gas Oil Sands Oil Sands Growth Program olanzapine old-growth logging oligarchy Online Training Ontario Ontario contractors Ontario manufacturing Order of Canada orders granting Pacific Coast Pacific Link pipeline Pacific Northwest Pacific Salmon Foundation Pacific Salmon Treaty party dynamics Pembina Percy Starr pharmaceutical industry Pharmaceutical Row Pharmascience Philosophy Pierre Poilievre pipe tobacco pipeline proposal pipes Plutonic Power policy critique political analysis political economy political satire Potlatch power practices Prince George Prince Rupert productivity crisis proposed provincial cooperation psychotropic medications Public Policy Pulse Camera 1 Quatsino Quebec Quebec2026 Rainbow Motel rare Red Seal Regional Power regulations Replantation Residential Schools Resource Management resource towns Resources rhetoric vs reality Rights and Title RIP Chris Charlie robotics royalties RPF run-of-river run‑of‑river rural rural economy s S-100a course S100A Course sadism safety Salmon salmon agriculture salmon aquaculture salmon farming Salmon Farms salmon returns salmon table process Salmonix Saskatchewan satire Scott Lunny seign boat self-government Seminars siding and eavestrough Silviculture Site C Skills Smoke Rings Smokers Delight Social Capital Social Evolution sockeye softwood lumber tariffs specialty StatsCan sushi sustainability math Swindle Island systemic racism Taseko’s New Prosperity mine proposal taxpayer perspective Teal-Jones technology Television History Teẑtan Biny Threads of Life Toba River Tobacco tobacconist Trade Trade Show News Traditional territory Training Transporation Tree Nurseries tree planters Tribal Chief trout true genius Trump tariffs Tŝilhqot’in elders Tsilhqot’in Nation Tŝilhqot’in National Government U.S. energy boom U'mista UBCBuilt UBCBuilt Olympian UNDRIP Union United States university unpaid input Uranium urban usage USMCA Vancouver Island Volunteer west coast west coast fisheries West Coast Vancouver Island West Fraser West Island Montreal Western Canada Forestry WFCA WFCA Annual Meeting 2026 WFCA Conference 2027 WFCA2026 Wildfire management Wildfire prevention Wildfire Training Wildwood Winnipeg Women in forestry wood recycle Work Safety Xeni Gwet’in Xeni Gwet’in First Nations Government YAP youth Zyprexa